Absentive
Data d'edició: 19 de Febrer de 2014
Data d'actualització: 07 de Març de 2014
Data d'actualització: 07 de Març de 2014
Autoria:
Mar Garachana The absentive consists in the grammatical expression of absence. Thus, the absentive is a grammatical procedure specialised in highlighting that one person, who at the utterance time is performing some activity, is not present in a specific place. For instance, in Italian, the utterance É a mangiare ‘He has gone to lunch” implies that a person is performing the action of eating in a different space from the person who is speaking. Sometimes the absentive is called absentive aspect; notwithstanding, the absentive is not exactly the expression of the verbal aspect.
Contents
Communicative situations that favour the absentive
Discussion about the absentive existence
Explanation
In some languages —such as Spanish or English—, there is not a grammatical structure specialised in marking someone’s absence. This information is contextually inferred or expressed by lexical means. In contrast, other languages do have specialized grammatical structure to marking the absence.
In English or Spanish, the utterance of (1) will be uttered whether Joseph/Pepe is eating in a shared place with the speaker or not. Instead, in Catalan, the sentence of (2) is only highlighting a progressive aspect of the action. By contrast, the statement of (3) emphasizes that the action of eating takes place in a spaced not shared. That is, the utterance of (3), in Catalan, indicates the absence of Pep.
(1) Joseph is eating
Pepe está comiendo
‘Pepe is eating’
(2) En Pep està dinant
(3) En Pep està a dinar
‘Pep is off eating’
Something similar happens in Italian, where (4) only expresses the progressive nature of the action, while (5) stresses Silvio’s absence.
(4) Silvio sta mangiando
(5) Silvio é a mangiare
‘Silvio is off eating’
The absentive expresses four kinds of information about the referent of the subject:
- The subjecte is absent
- The subject is performing an activity
- How long will the subject be absent is predictable
- The subject will come back after a period of time
The European languages that have a grammatical construction for expressing the absentive are German, Frisian, Dutch, Hungarian, Italian, Norwegian, Swedish, Finnish and Catalan.
Syntactic structures used for absentive expression are:
(i) Copula+ infinitive
(6) German
Jan ist boxen
Jan is box:INF (de Groot 2000)
‘Jan is off boxing’
(ii) Copula+ at + infinitive
(7) Catalan
En Pere és a patinar
Pere is at sk:INF
‘Pere is off skating’
(iii) Copula+ and + finite verb
(8) Norwegian
Jan er og boksar
Jan is and box:PRES (de Groot 2000)
‘Jan is off boxing’
(iv) Copula + to + infinitive
(9) Fering (north Frisian dialect)
Jan as tu boksin
Jan is to box:INF (de Groot 2000)
‘Jan is off boxing’
(v) Copula + infinitive-inessive
(10) Finnish
Jussi on nykkeile-mä-ssä
Jussi is box-3INF-INESS (de Groot 2000)
‘Jan is off boxing’
Communicative situations that favour the absentive
Absentive is specially frequent in communicative exchanges consisting of a dialogical sequence, like the one in (6), taken from Hungarian.
(6) A. Peterrel szeretnék beszélni
Peter:COM like: COND:1SG speak
B. De hiszen úszni van
Well swim:INF is (de Groot 2000)
‘A. I would like to speak with Peter
B. Well, he is off swimming
Absentive is also characteristic of the notes hanged on the doors in order to indicate that somebody has gone out, as the following taken from Catalan:
(7) Estic a fer un encàrrec
‘I am off on an errand’
In some languages, absentive is expressed with some syntactic constructions very similar to those of the progressive aspect. So, in Old and Early Middle English, it was documented an absentive construction, which would give place to the progressive aspect.
Absentive imposes lexical restrictions to the verbs that can appear in the absentive construction. Thus, only agentive verbs can appear; verbs lacking an agent typically cannot be used in the absentive construction. Similarly, in some languages absentivity cannot be expressed through a passive voice. In both cases, the restrictions imposed seem to come from the fact that a subject typically involves an agentive subject controlling the action. Hence, the great propensity to agentive verbs and the short presence of passive voice, that emphasizes the patient rather than the agent.
Discussion about the absentive existence
The existence of the absentive is controversial, since some authors consider that the expression of absence is not a grammatically codified piece of information, but an effect of meaning of some constructions that also express other values.
Related concepts
Progressive Aspect
Related links
The absentive: http://www.lotpublications.nl/publish/articles/002545/bookpart.pdf
Basic bibliography
de Groot, Casper (2000), “The absentive”, in Dahl, Östen (ed.), Tense and Aspect in the Languages of Europe, Berlin, Mouton de Gruyter, pp. 693-719.
Additional bibliography
Bertinetto, Pier Marco - Ebert, Karen H. - de Groot, Casper (2000), “The progressive in Europe”, in Dahl, Östen (ed.), Tense and Aspect in the Languages of Europe, Berlin, Mouton de Gruyter, pp. 517-558.
de Groot, Casper (2007), “The king os on huntunge: On the relation between progressive and absentive in Old and Early Modern English”, in Hannay, Mike and Steen, Gerard J. (eds.), Structural-functional Studies in English Grammar: In Honour of Lachlan Mackenzie, Amsterdam, John Benjamins, pp. 175-190.
Werner, Abraham (2007), “Absent arguments on the absentive: Grammatical Category or just Pragmatic Inference?”, in Groninger Arbeiten zur germanistischen Linguistik, 45, 3-16.
